If you’re thinking about buying a home, one of the most common questions is how…
Nearly 3 in 10 Phoenix listings have already had a cut. Has the ask actually met the market?
Downtown Phoenix, Arizona skyline. Photo: Wikimedia Commons contributor, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
As Phoenix housing market price cuts reached 29.5% of active listings in Phoenix-Mesa-Chandler in October—among the highest shares in realtor.com’s 50-metro table—sellers are asking whether their asking prices have truly met the market. The median list price was $475,000, down 4.0%. New listings were down 11.3%. When nearly 3 in 10 listings have already been cut, the question is whether the ask has actually met the market.
That question is sharper for a relocation seller with a deadline, in Goodyear, Litchfield Park, Avondale, Buckeye or Surprise. A seller who has to close cannot treat waiting as a strategy. A token cut on top of a cut that already failed is not a strategy either. Show today’s payment at the current ask, next to the competing West Valley listings, and name the checkpoint before the listing goes live.
Why Phoenix Housing Market Price Cuts Have Climbed as Western Sales Slow
The National Association of Realtors reported on November 12 that existing-home sales fell 5.5% from September and 8.8% from a year earlier, to a 3.75 million seasonally adjusted annual rate, the lowest pace since August 2010. Lawrence Yun, NAR’s chief economist, tied that drop to mortgage rates at their highest levels since 2000, aside from a single month in 2023.
Prices have not followed sales down. The median existing-home sale price was $416,700, up 0.4% from a year earlier, the 40th straight month of year-over-year increases. Distressed sales were only 2% of October transactions. Yun said the country’s 88 million homeowners are “largely in a comfortable financial position due to sizable housing wealth accumulation.”
Is it really the price, or is the market just dead?
On November 9 a homeowner put that question to other realtors. The house had been listed for close to six combined months. It was already the lowest by $10,000 among 12 similar listings, and it had had one showing in a month. Competing houses the poster checked were also getting no showings, after cuts and delistings that had not helped.
The poster had no need to move, was leaving only because of the weather, and asked whether a further $25,000 cut would be a poor decision. In the same stretch of road, the poster said, one nearby home listed and sold in a month for $400,000, and another went to foreclosure and sold for $310,000. Those two sales are one person’s account, not official statistics. The poster’s ask was $365,000, and the house had no driveway and only a side yard.
A small cut is not the same as a price that can sell.
About one in five U.S. listings already had a price cut in October, 20.5%, according to realtor.com, only 0.2 points above a year earlier. Jake Krimmel, who wrote the report, put the mood in a heading: “Sellers freeze rather than panic.” New listings fell 7.5% from a year earlier, the steepest drop since September 2023. The delisting rate was 4.4%, against 4.6% a year earlier.
A 29.5% cut share means most of the competitive set has already tried a reduction. If showings are still thin, the next conversation is whether the ask, the condition, or the presentation is the part that has not met the market, especially when a relocation date is fixed.
A cut from an ask that was never realistic can look large and still change nothing. In a separate thread, a listing agent described a seller who treated a $70,000 drop as a huge concession, after the house had been listed about $70,000 too high because of an incorrect square-footage figure. The original price, the agent wrote, was never realistic to begin with. A token cut is not a strategy.
Agree on the checkpoint before the listing goes live.
There is no single national figure for how many days should pass before a price change. One useful practice is to set the checkpoint in advance, so the later conversation is less personal. If showings in the first 10 days fall short of an agreed number, or if feedback keeps naming the same issue, the ask or the presentation gets another look. The trigger should be named before the sign goes up.
Two widely quoted clocks measure different things and should not be treated as a rule. NAR’s median time on market for homes that sold in October was 35 days. realtor.com’s median for listings was 63 days. One is a sold-home figure. The other is a listing figure. Neither tells a seller when to cut.
Show the seller a payment, not only a price.
The useful work a loan officer can do for a listing agent is not a product pitch. It is to show the seller today’s payment at the current ask, set next to the competing listings. NAR published a national illustration: on a $300,000 mortgage, the October average rate of 7.33% added about $216 a month compared with 6.25% a year earlier. That is an example, not an offer, and it is a national figure.
On the buyer side, a verified pre-approval helps an agent write an offer a seller of a stale listing might actually answer. A low number without proof that the buyer can close is easier to ignore.
Many sellers can wait, and that is why some listings sit.
Yun’s point about homeowners’ equity, and the 2% distressed-sale share, explain a lot of the freeze. realtor.com’s Krimmel put it bluntly: “you do not list into weak demand unless you need to.” Sellers who can wait often do. The November 9 poster said outright there was no need to move. Unsold inventory has moved closer to a more balanced level: a 5.1-month supply in October, up from 4.7 in September and 4.4 a year earlier, which NAR’s accompanying story calls “a level considered more balanced.”
Waiting for rates to fall is a possibility, not a date.
Yun said that, given the current sales pace at a time of consistent job growth, “there could be sizable pent-up demand if mortgage rates decline.” realtor.com’s base case is that rates “remain above 7% in the near term.” Both statements are judgments about what might happen, not a calendar. If the seller needs to close, the ask still has to meet the buyers who are here now. If the seller can wait, waiting is a real choice, not a failure.
A downtown Phoenix, Arizona building with palm trees. Photo: davidpinter, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Common questions
Why isn’t my house selling after a price cut?
The cut may have been too small to change how buyers see the monthly payment, or the issue may be the house itself, the way it is presented, or the seller’s timeline, not only the ask. Official listing data show that price cuts are common, but they are not always larger or more frequent than they were a year ago.
How many days on market before I should drop the price?
There is no single national number. NAR’s median time on market for homes that sold in October was 35 days. realtor.com’s median for listings was 63 days. Those two figures measure different things, and neither is a rule for when to cut. Agree on a checkpoint, in advance, based on showings and feedback as well as time.
Is the housing market frozen, or are homes just overpriced?
October existing-home sales were the slowest since August 2010, but the median sale price was still up 0.4%, and distressed sales were only 2%. Some listings are priced for a market that has already moved. A slower market is not a crash.
Should I wait for mortgage rates to fall before changing the ask?
Lawrence Yun, NAR’s chief economist, says there could be “sizable pent-up demand if mortgage rates decline.” That is a possibility, not a date. realtor.com’s base case is that rates “remain above 7% in the near term.” If you need to sell, the ask still has to meet the buyers who are here now.
Mortgage and Credit Pro can help a listing agent run that payment comparison at mortgageandcreditpro.com.
This post is general education, not a loan offer. John Werner, NMLS #150553. Mortgage and Credit Pro is a dba of Northwest Funding Group, Inc., Company NMLS 101770. Equal Housing Opportunity.

